Watch Freeks banner

Panerai movement scandal...

127K views 56 replies 32 participants last post by  AtomicTom  
#1 ·
imported post

There is a big controversy currently going on in the Paneristi world regarding the movements that were used in the PAM 318 Special Edition "Brooklyn Bridge" watches. Instead of having a decorated movements, like the OPII from the PAM 414 installed, subpar movements have been utilized in the PAM 318. As you look at the pictures below and read the links, please keep in mind that the 318 is a $5,000 watch! These are two threads that go through the entire story, with all of the sorted details...

http://www.network54.com/Forum/353391/m ... ous+PAM318

http://www.network54.com/Forum/353391/t ... ners+Unite


Let's start with a couple of pics of this BEAUTIFUL watch!

Image
Image
Image
Image




Here you have some pics from the PAM 414 movement (OP II) and the PAM 318 movement (OP XXIX) The movement from the PAM 414 is presented first, with the corresponding picture of the PAM 318 movement right after...quite a difference and I can see why folks are up in arms about this!

Image
Image
Image
Image
Image
Image
Image
Image
Image
Image
Image
Image
Image
Image
Image
Image
Image
Image


^

^

|

|

IMO that is a complete disgrace and OP should offer all owners of the PAM 318 either - A full refund, A replacement movment and/or free inspection to satisfy any current owners angziety over this issue!
 
#52 ·
Are we sure this is not a knock-off from China?Because that movement has cheapest Chinese movements written all over it....I must say though, some higher end knock offs from China has better movement deco. than this...
 
#56 ·
This thing is really ironic. With all the jokes about selling the Brooklyn bridge and all. I have three watches with this movement in them. One is decorated, two are not. Guess what, you put them on a timegrapher and there is like no difference between them.
However, like what plenty have pointed out beforehand. You should get what you're paying for no matter how little the difference is. Especially when you're talking about a 150 piece limited edition run. I guess Panerai underestimated how many people would take the time to actually open up a solid case back watch. I always do because first and foremost, I am a movement guy.
What I see here as the major sin is not so much the decoration of the movement that no one will ever see. It's the pedestrian Novodiac retention system holding the balance wheel jewel as compared to the best ever created Incabloc that was promised in the original advertisement.
Somebody above mentioned something about the sum of a watch. An example of this is the Panerai with its big reputation going for 5 grand. When you can buy a Laco Cuxhaven which features an enamel dial, much better construction and the same decorated movement with an exhibition case back for all to enjoy for 1 grand.
Gotta love this hobby...:)