That's funny you asked that James, because the Tattooed "cook" asked me the same question on Tuesday. The one on the left is actually gunmetal, as opposed to the black. With that slight haze in my pics, you can't tell the difference. You really have to get an up-close look at them when holding them.that picture of your watch box makes me want to ..... WEEP.
Question - do you have 2 of the same exact watch (second from the top left and second from the top right)?